It’s Saturday night. You’re a single guy with a bowl of popcorn in one hand and the remote in the other. Suddenly, a ping lights up your phone. It’s a message from her. You know who I’m talking about: the girl who seems to float three inches off the ground, speaks fluent charity work, and looks like an angel escaped from a Pinterest board. She’s perfect—or is she?
Before you dive headlong into cloud nine, let’s have a little chat. As a Christian single guy who has been around the block (in a metaphorical sense; let’s not get carried away), I’ve learned a thing or two about dating women who seem too good to be true. Let’s explore why this glittering perfection might actually be a red flag—and how to keep our hearts anchored in Christ while navigating the wild world of dating.
1. The Danger of Pedestals
First things first: pedestals are for art, not for relationships. When you date someone who appears perfect, you might unconsciously start putting them on a pedestal. This can lead to all kinds of problems—like ignoring red flags because you’ve convinced yourself they can do no wrong.
Here’s the Christian kicker: only God is perfect. Romans 3:23 tells us, “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” Yep, even her. When we start treating someone like they’re flawless, we’re not only deceiving ourselves but also setting them up for failure. No one can live up to that kind of pressure.
2. The Checklist Syndrome
Let’s talk about the infamous “Christian Checklist.” She volunteers every weekend? Check. She sings on the worship team? Double-check. She quotes C.S. Lewis in casual conversation? Triple-check!
While there’s nothing wrong with being attracted to someone’s good qualities, we need to make sure we’re not idolizing them. The danger here is that our focus shifts from who she really is to who we want her to be. And when reality doesn’t match the fantasy, disappointment is inevitable.
3. Beware of Love Bombing
Ever heard of “love bombing”? It’s when someone showers you with attention, compliments, and affection so intensely that it feels like you’re living in a Nicholas Sparks novel. While it can be flattering, it can also be manipulative.
As Christian men, we need to guard our hearts (Proverbs 4:23). A whirlwind romance might feel exciting, but true love takes time to grow. If you’re feeling overwhelmed by someone’s perfection, take a step back and pray for discernment. God’s wisdom will help you see what’s real and what’s just emotional fireworks.
4. Perfectionism Hides Vulnerability
Here’s a little secret: sometimes, people who seem too good to be true are hiding something. Perfectionism can be a mask for insecurity or fear of rejection. As Christians, we’re called to love authentically—not just the shiny, Instagram-worthy parts of someone, but their messy, human side too.
When you’re dating, don’t just focus on her highlight reel. Ask her about her struggles, her doubts, and her dreams. Authenticity is the soil where a Christ-centered relationship grows.
Christian Advice for Navigating the “Perfect” Relationship
Now that we’ve talked about the dangers, let’s get practical. Here’s how to date wisely and biblically when you’re tempted to chase the “too good to be true” dream:
1. Pray for Discernment
Before you swipe right or say yes to that coffee date, take it to the Lord in prayer. James 1:5 reminds us, “If any of you lacks wisdom, you should ask God, who gives generously to all without finding fault, and it will be given to you.” Pray for clarity, wisdom, and a heart that seeks God’s will above all else.
2. Seek Godly Counsel
Got a trusted pastor, mentor, or best friend who can keep you grounded? Great! Ask them what they think. Sometimes, we’re too close to the situation to see clearly. A wise friend can help us spot potential red flags—or confirm that this girl is genuinely awesome.
3. Keep Christ at the Center
Here’s the golden rule of Christian dating: if she pulls you closer to Christ, that’s a good sign. If she distracts you from your relationship with God, it’s time to reevaluate. Matthew 6:33 says, “But seek first his kingdom and his righteousness, and all these things will be given to you as well.” Your spiritual growth should never take a backseat to romance.
4. Don’t Rush
Ecclesiastes 3:1 reminds us, “There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under the heavens.” Just because she seems perfect doesn’t mean you need to sprint down the aisle tomorrow. Take your time to build a solid foundation of friendship, trust, and mutual respect.
5. Look for Humility
True beauty isn’t found in Instagram filters or a sparkling personality. It’s found in humility, kindness, and a heart that seeks God. Proverbs 31:30 puts it perfectly: “Charm is deceptive, and beauty is fleeting; but a woman who fears the Lord is to be praised.”
When Perfection Isn’t the Goal
Let me leave you with this thought: God didn’t create us to be perfect for each other. He created us to be perfected in Christ. When we stop looking for “too good to be true” and start seeking someone who’s real, honest, and God-centered, we open the door for the kind of love that reflects His grace.
So the next time you meet someone who seems like the total package, take a breath. Pray. Seek wisdom. And remember: the goal isn’t to find someone who completes you (Jesus already did that). It’s to find someone who walks with you, side by side, as you both grow closer to Him.
Happy dating, my friends. And may your popcorn bowl never run empty.
0 Comments